Pennock Point in Jupiter sold 5 homes in 12 months, $1.55 million to $9 million. Half-acre lots, new builds near $4.1 million. What the land is worth.
Pennock Point in Jupiter is where you buy the land. Five homes sold there in the last 12 months, from $1,550,000 to $9,000,000 (Flexmls pulled 2026-10-17). One 1966 house on a half acre on Hibiscus Road sold for $1.2 million in August 2025. The new house on that lot sold for $4.1 million in July 2026.
Watch the Full Video · Watch the short version
Pennock Point in Jupiter: the short answer
Pennock Point in Jupiter is where you buy the land. Five homes sold there in the last 12 months, from $1,550,000 to $9,000,000 (Flexmls pulled 2026-10-17). One 1966 house on a half acre on Hibiscus Road sold for $1.2 million in August 2025. The new house on that lot sold for $4.1 million in July 2026.
That is the whole market in two sales. Most of what you will see here is a half-acre lot, and the house on it is either brand new, renovated, or waiting for somebody to decide. Double-check the listing you are interested in, because five sales is a small sample.
Every Pennock Point sale in the last 12 months
Closed sales in Pennock Point and Pennock Pointe Estates, Jupiter 33458, October 17, 2025 to October 17, 2026 (Flexmls, pulled 2026-10-17):
| Address | Closed | Price | Built | Lot | Waterfront |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5387 Pennock Point Road | January 2026 | $9,000,000 | 1992 | 0.78 acre | Yes |
| 5634 Shirley Drive | July 2026 | $4,120,000 | 2026 | 0.50 acre | No |
| 5528 Hibiscus Road | July 2026 | $4,100,000 | 2026 | 0.50 acre | No |
| 5661 Old Mystic Court (Pennock Pointe Estates) | December 2025 | $1,600,000 | 1995 | 0.53 acre | No |
| 5686 Shirley Drive | April 2026 | $1,550,000 | 1973 | 0.52 acre | No |
Just before that window, on October 9, 2025, a 1973 house on 1.05 acres at 5620 Pennock Point Road closed at $2,500,000 (Flexmls, pulled 2026-10-17). Five sales is thin, so I am showing you each one. An average of $9 million and $1.5 million describes no house on the point.
Riverfront vs dry lot: two different markets
The riverfront homes sit along Pennock Point Road. Only one sold inside the last 12 months, at $9 million. Earlier Flexmls records show riverfront sales at $8,150,000 in January 2025 and $6,668,044 in June 2025. One riverfront home is on the market today at $19,999,000, listed 163 days (Flexmls, pulled 2026-10-17).
The dry lots are everything else, mostly half-acre lots on streets like Shirley Drive and Hibiscus Road. In the last 12 months they sold from $1.55 million for an original 1973 house to about $4.1 million for a new build.
Before you pay for water, ask the boating questions for the exact property: frontage in feet, dock permit, lift capacity, seawall condition and any fixed bridges between the dock and open water. Get every answer in writing.
The lot is the asset
Straight talk: on the dry side of Pennock Point, the lot is what you are buying. The house is a decision you make after closing.
Look at Hibiscus Road. A 1966 house on a half acre sold for $1.2 million in August 2025. By July 2026 a new home stood on that lot and sold for $4.1 million. On Shirley Drive, an original 1973 house sold for $1.55 million in April 2026, and a new build on the same street sold for $4.12 million in July.
So the question is not whether this house is worth $1.5 million. It is whether this half acre is worth $1.5 million to you, and what you will spend on it.
What to watch out for before you write the offer:
What the lot will let you build. Ask the municipality or county that governs the parcel about setbacks, flood zone, elevation and any tree rules, and get a survey early.
What the current house is worth to you. Renovate, live in it while you plan, or take it down. Each one is a different budget.
How long you can wait. A rebuild on Hibiscus Road went from a $1.2 million sale in August 2025 to a $4.1 million sale in July 2026, under a year, according to the Flexmls record.
That is what The Wilder Way Home is built for. It is our free buyer's guide to Palm Beach County, including how to tell what you are paying for the land and what you are paying for the house.
You'll also get our monthly Buyer Edition. Unsubscribe anytime.
Rather talk it through? Brian Wilder, 561-201-4717, or book a Buyer Discovery Call below.
Three communities share the Pennock name
This trips up buyers searching "Pennock Point." Pines on Pennock Lane (including the Paseos section), Pennock Landing and Prado at Pennock Preserve are separate Jupiter communities. They are not on the point, they carry association fees, and their prices run much lower.
Flexmls, pulled 2026-10-17, closed sales October 17, 2025 to October 17, 2026:
| Measure | Pennock Point and Pennock Pointe Estates | Pines on Pennock Lane, Pennock Landing, Prado at Pennock Preserve |
|---|---|---|
| Sales | 5 | 12 |
| Price range | $1,550,000 to $9,000,000 | $519,000 to $2,825,000 |
| Lot size on record | about a half acre on four of five | 0.13 to 0.35 acre where a lot size is listed |
| Association fee on record | none on the four Pennock Point records; $125 a month in Pennock Pointe Estates | a fee on 11 of the 12 records |
If a listing says "Pennock" and the price looks too good, check the subdivision name first.
Pennock Pointe Estates and the history in the street names
Pennock Pointe Estates is a small enclave on Old Mystic Court. Its one sale in the last 12 months closed at $1.6 million, with an association fee of $125 a month on the record (Flexmls, pulled 2026-10-17).
One of the point's streets is Old Fort Jupiter Road. Fort Jupiter was built in 1838 after a battle with Seminole Indians on the Loxahatchee River, according to the Historical Society of Palm Beach County.
Confirm zoned schools for the exact address with the School District of Palm Beach County before you offer.
Weighing other water? Read our guide to North Palm Beach waterfront homes. Want a club instead of a half acre? Read our Admirals Cove guide.
Selling your current home too?
Most buyers at this price are selling something to do it, and a rebuild makes the timing harder. You may close on the lot, keep your current home while you design and permit, and sell later. Or you may need to sell first and rent. Either way, the sale and the build have to be planned together.
Our seller guide lays out how we line up both sides. If you want a number on your current home first, start with What's My Home Worth.
Get The Wilder Way to a Stress-Free Sale
You'll also get our monthly Homeowner Edition. Unsubscribe anytime.
Talk to Brian about Pennock Point
Walk the lot before you walk the house. Stand in the backyard, look at the trees and the neighbors, and ask what you would build if the house were not there. If the answer excites you more than the house does, you already know which buyer you are.
Get The Wilder Way Home before you make an offer, and book a call when you are ready to line up the numbers.
You'll also get our monthly Buyer Edition. Unsubscribe anytime.
Frequently asked questions
How much do homes cost in Pennock Point, Jupiter?+
Does Pennock Point have an HOA?+
Is Pennock Point waterfront?+
Is Pennock Point the same as Pines on Pennock Lane or Pennock Landing?+
Are people tearing down homes in Pennock Point?+
What is a half acre in Pennock Point worth?+
Brian Wilder 561-201-4717 | Lucy Lopez 561-285-8809 | Keller Williams Realty
Wilder Real Estate Group at Keller Williams Realty. Fifth-generation Palm Beach County resident, second-generation agent, licensed since 1998, in business since 1996, 1,500+ closed transactions (team total, per Wilder Real Estate Group transaction records, as of 2026-10-17).
Market figures are from Flexmls (BeachesMLS) as of October 17, 2026 and change daily. Waterfront and association-fee details are as recorded on MLS listings; confirm for any specific property. This page is independent buyer education and is not affiliated with any association, builder or developer.